Botafogo knocked Sao Paulo out on penalties 5-4, after a 1-1 draw. Sao Paulo created more — chances worth 1.9 goals — and deserved better. Sao Paulo controlled the ball — 59% possession — but had nothing to show for it. Botafogo played with ten from minute 90. Best on the pitch was D. Bobadilla, rated 7.5.

1. 0'
   ⚽Kick-off
   CONMEBOL Libertadores 2024
   BRA 4-2-3-1·4-2-3-1 BRA
   Coach: L. Zubeldía · Artur JorgeReferee: D. Herrera📍 MorumBIS
2. 1. First half
   2. 15'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!Thiago Almada
   3. 36'
      BRA
      Substitution
      ▲Luciano▼William
   4. 45+2'
      BRA
      Yellow card
      Alex Terra
3. 1. Second half
   2. 49'
      BRA
      Yellow card
      John
   3. 53'
      BRA
      Yellow card
      D. Bobadilla
   4. 60'
      BRA
      Substitution
      ▲Adryelson▼Alex Terra
   5. 70'
      BRA
      Substitution
      ▲Matheus Martins▼Luiz Henrique
   6. 70'
      BRA
      Substitution
      ▲Tchê Tchê▼J. Savarino
   7. 75'
      BRA
      Substitution
      ▲Rodrigo Nestor▼D. Bobadilla
   8. 75'
      BRA
      Substitution
      ▲Igor Vinicius▼Rafinha
   9. 79'
      BRA
      Yellow card
      Rodrigo Nestor
   10. 83'
       BRA
       Substitution
       ▲André Silva▼Wellington Rato
   11. 83'
       BRA
       Substitution
       ▲M. Araújo▼Welington
   12. 83'
       BRA
       Substitution
       ▲Marçal▼Alex Telles
   13. 83'
       BRA
       Substitution
       ▲Danilo Barbosa▼Gregore
   14. 87'
       BRA
       GOOOAL!CalleriAssist: André Silva
   15. 90+2'
       BRA
       Red card
       Gatito Fernández
   16. 90+2'
       BRA
       Yellow card
       Rafinha
   17. 90+2'
       BRA
       Yellow card
       Rafinha
   18. 90+2'
       BRA
       Yellow card
       Marçal
   19. 90+7'
       BRA
       Yellow card
       Igor Vinicius
4. 1. Penalties
   2. 120+1'
      BRA
      Shootout miss
      Calleri
   3. 120+2'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!Tchê TchêPenalty shootout
   4. 120+3'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!Luiz GustavoPenalty shootout
   5. 120+4'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!Danilo BarbosaPenalty shootout
   6. 120+5'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!Lucas MouraPenalty shootout
   7. 120+6'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!MarçalPenalty shootout
   8. 120+7'
      BRA
      GOOOAL!Igor ViniciusPenalty shootout
   9. 120+8'
      BRA
      Shootout miss
      Vitinho
   10. 120+9'
       BRA
       GOOOAL!LucianoPenalty shootout
   11. 120+10'
       BRA
       GOOOAL!Thiago AlmadaPenalty shootout
   12. 120+11'
       BRA
       Shootout miss
       Rodrigo Nestor
   13. 120+12'
       BRA
       GOOOAL!Matheus MartinsPenalty shootout